CELL-AED Defibrillator Comparison
Update 12/04/2023: We’ve updated this article with CELL-AED’s recent price changes and additional information on clinical trials, energy output, and defibrillating infants.
At DDI Safety, we aim to make understanding defibrillators straightforward. Many customers have asked us about the new CELL-AED defibrillators, which target the home market with a low cost of entry. Should you consider one? In this article, we compare the CELL-AED defibrillator to other models based on available information.
Is CELL-AED the Best Value Defibrillator?
A base CELL-AED costs $499. This is a low upfront cost. However, CELL-AEDs have a limited lifespan compared to some other defibrillators. The latest CELL-AEDs have a lifespan of approximately two years. Therefore, over eight years, you would need to purchase four CELL-AEDs, costing around $1996, assuming no further price increases.
In comparison, a Heartsine 350p/360p has an estimated total cost of $1800 over eight years. This cost includes the initial purchase price and necessary maintenance. Based on these figures, the Heartsine defibrillator appears to be slightly cheaper over this period.
| Price | Cell-AED | Heartsine 350p/360p |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Cost | $499 | $1590 |
| Est. Cost over 8 Years | $1996 | $1800 |
| Est. Cost over 12 Years | $2994 | $2010 |
| Maintenance Cost: Verified Cardiac Event | $499 | Free |
| Maintenance Cost: Non-Cardiac Event | $499 | $210 |
It’s important to consider that CELL-AED offers an optional subscription plan that reduces the initial cost to $399 with a monthly fee of $16.50. Over eight years, this totals approximately $1993.
Longevity of Defibrillators
When investing in a defibrillator, longevity is a crucial factor. Heartsine and Lifepak defibrillators offer an eight-year warranty. Their pads and batteries typically have a four-year shelf life.
CELL-AED defibrillators require replacement every 13 months, but with their subscription model ($16.50 per month or $198 per year), you can receive a replacement unit as needed.
| Model | Cell-AED | Heartsine 350/360/500p | Lifepak CR2 & Essential |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warranty | 2 Years | 8 Years | 8 Years |
| Pad/Battery Shelf Life | 2 Years | 4 Years | 4 Years |
Performance and Results
Another vital consideration is the performance of the defibrillator. Energy output is measured in joules, and the Australian Resuscitation Council recommends an initial energy output of 200 joules. CELL-AED’s maximum output is 85 joules, which is lower than this recommendation.
Higher energy defibrillators, such as the Lifepak CR2, can deliver up to 360 joules.
In a cardiac emergency, every second counts. The quicker a defibrillator can deliver a shock, the better the chances of survival. The time it takes for a defibrillator to charge and deliver a shock is crucial.
| Model | Cell-AED | Heartsine 350/360p/500p | Lifepak CR2 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum Joules | 85 | 200 | 360 |
| Shock Charging Time | <25 seconds | 8-12 seconds | 7-13 seconds |
Infant Defibrillation
The design of the CELL-AED presents unique challenges when used on infants. Users need to remove the top pad after delivering a shock and place it on the ground before performing CPR, then reattach the pad for the next cycle. This process can cause delays, which might impact the effectiveness of the device in critical situations.
Minimizing interruptions to CPR is crucial for successful resuscitation. The design of CELL-AED may inadvertently cause delays, potentially affecting its effectiveness in emergencies.
Conclusion
We hope this article has provided helpful information about the CELL-AED defibrillator. While it offers a low cost of entry, defibrillators like the Heartsine 350p/360p may be more cost-effective in the long run, offering higher energy output and robust design backed by extensive research.
-
Lifepak CR2 Essential Automatic AED$2,250.00 -
-
Hey there fellow Defibrillator afficiando! I'm Jack, a first aid trainer based in beautiful Penrith, NSW at the foot of the Blue Mountains. I love helping take complicated subjects and making them easy and understandable. When I'm not first aiding, you can find me birding and listening to jangle pop.
